The way to compare small business insurance quotes, whether bought direct or through a broker, is to give every source the same description of the business and the same coverage types, limits and deductibles, then read what each policy excludes before looking at the premium. A broker such as Insureon can return several options through one conversation, while buying direct means requesting each quote separately from a carrier such as Hiscox, NEXT Insurance (now branded ERGO NEXT) or The Hartford. Insureon reports an average general liability premium of $45 a month across roughly 100,000 of its own customers, but that figure describes its own book of business and not the market.
Should a small business buy direct or through a broker?
Neither route is better for every business. A broker saves effort when a business wants several options without approaching each company separately. Buying direct gives a business a single relationship with the insurer that writes the policy, and it can be quicker when the business already knows which carrier it wants.
The comparison problem is identical on both routes. A quote only means something next to another quote for the same business, so the discipline matters more than the channel: the same description of the work, the same revenue and payroll, the same location, the same coverage types and the same limits. Premiums depend on trade, payroll, revenue and location, so no published figure can predict what a particular business will pay.
One concession is worth making plainly. A broker is the more natural fit for a business that has no preferred carrier and wants breadth quickly. Direct suits a buyer who has already settled on a company and wants to deal with it alone.
What is the difference between a broker and a carrier?
A carrier is the insurer that writes the policy and takes on the risk. A broker arranges cover with insurers and is not the insurer itself. That changes what the reader is buying: with a broker, the contract and the claims relationship may sit with an insurer the broker places the business with.
Three questions apply to either route. Who issues the policy? Who handles a claim? And what does the policy exclude? A broker does not change the answer to the third question, because the exclusions belong to the policy and not to the seller.
The options, in alphabetical order
The providers below are listed alphabetically, and the order is not a ranking. Prices are as of October 13, 2026, were read at each provider's own pages, and move over time. Every figure belongs to the company that published it and describes that company's own customers or products, not the market.
Chubb. Chubb publishes no small-business premium, and it quotes per business. A business that wants Chubb in the comparison has to request a quote for the same cover as the others.
Hiscox. Hiscox states that general liability starts at $30 a month. Its page lists business size, industry, location and coverage amount as what moves the price. The figure is a floor and not a typical price.
Insureon. Insureon is a broker, not a carrier. It reports an average general liability premium of $45 a month, with 22% of its customers under $30 and 41% between $30 and $60, and annual policies from $265 to $3,030. Those figures are the median of policies it sold to roughly 100,000 of its own small business customers, and they should not be read as what the market charges. It is the broker option in this comparison, and the one to weigh against buying direct.
NEXT Insurance. The company now brands itself ERGO NEXT. It says general liability starts at $19 a month for some businesses, and it reports that 45% of its customers pay $45 a month or less. Its published trade examples run from about $20 a month for a personal trainer to about $245 a month for a restaurant, and the page itself says an exact price needs a quote.
The Hartford. The Hartford publishes an average of about $810 a year, or about $67 a month, for general liability. That is the carrier's own average across its customers, and its page says costs vary by state and that a specific premium could be higher or lower.
Thimble. Thimble publishes no premium on its site and quotes per business. Its distinguishing feature is short-term and by-the-job cover, so it should be compared on that and not on price.
| Provider | Route | What it publishes | What the figure describes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chubb | Direct | No premium published | Quotes per business |
| Hiscox | Direct | General liability from $30 a month | A starting floor |
| Insureon | Broker | Average $45 a month; annual policies $265 to $3,030 | Median of policies sold to its own customers |
| NEXT Insurance | Direct | From $19 a month for some businesses; 45% of customers at $45 a month or less | Its own customers |
| The Hartford | Direct | About $810 a year, roughly $67 a month | Its own customers' average |
| Thimble | Direct | No premium published | Quotes per business |
What are the advantages of each route?
Through a broker, the main advantage is breadth for a single effort. One conversation can produce several options, which makes it easier to see how limits, deductibles and exclusions differ between insurers. The cost of that convenience is an extra party between the buyer and the insurer, so it matters to ask who issues the policy and who handles a claim.
Buying direct gives a clear, single line to the insurer. It can be quicker for a business that knows what it wants, and the carrier's own pages may publish a starting figure or an average to measure a quote against. The cost is that comparing means repeating the process with each company, and keeping each request identical takes discipline.
Can the published figures be compared across the two routes?
Not cleanly, and that is the central caution. Hiscox and ERGO NEXT state starting prices, The Hartford states an average across its customers, and Insureon states a median across the policies it sold. A starting price is the bottom of a range, and an average or median sits somewhere inside it.
Setting $19, $30, $45 and $67 side by side says little about which route is cheaper for a given business. Even inside one company the spread is wide: ERGO NEXT's own examples run from about $20 a month to about $245 a month. Only matching quotes settle the question.
What should every quote be checked against?
Start with what the law requires. The U.S. Small Business Administration states that the federal government requires every business with employees to carry workers' compensation, unemployment and disability insurance. It adds that some states require additional insurance and that laws requiring insurance vary by state. A quote that leaves a required cover unfilled is not a saving.
Then compare limits and deductibles. The limit is the most a policy will pay for a covered claim, and the deductible is what the business pays first. This page does not state typical limits or deductibles, so the step is to ask each source for the same figures in writing.
What do the exclusions look like?
This is where two similar premiums actually differ. The Insurance Information Institute says general liability protects against liability for bodily injury or property damage to others arising out of non-professional negligent acts. It also covers personal and advertising injury, including libel, slander, false arrest, infringing on another's copyright and malicious prosecution.
The exclusions are the real exposure. Workers' compensation and employment practices liability are excluded but can be bought as separate policies. Pollution liability is excluded and can be added as an endorsement. Liquor liability, professional liability and other risks may also be excluded, and without the extra liquor cover a standard policy does not protect a business against liquor-related claims.
A business owners policy bundles property insurance for buildings and contents the company owns, business interruption insurance for lost income after a fire or other catastrophe, and liability protection for harm the company may cause others. The Institute is direct about its limits: "BOPs do NOT cover professional liability, auto insurance, worker's compensation or health and disability insurance." Use the same exclusion checklist with a broker and with a carrier.
Does the choice of route change what an LLC needs?
No. The SBA says limited liability protects personal assets in most instances, but that the protection has limits. Forming an entity and buying a policy are separate steps that do different jobs.
If someone runs a single-member LLC, the entity separates the business from the owner in most instances, while a policy pays for covered claims the business faces. ZenBusiness is the entity half of that pairing. It sells no insurance of any kind and is not a broker, so it is not an option in the comparison above.
Where can the state's requirements be checked?
Beyond the federal rule for employers, insurance requirements are set by state, and this page does not state a requirement for any particular state. The place to confirm one is that state's own insurance department. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners publishes a small business insurance shopping tool, the Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner has a guide to how business insurance works, and the Texas Department of Insurance has a page on general liability insurance.
A business in another state should look for its own department's equivalent. Do this before accepting any quote, from a broker or a carrier.
How should the final decision be made?
Collect matching quotes first, from a broker, from carriers directly, or from both. Put limits, deductibles and exclusions side by side, and only then compare premiums. Confirm who issues each policy and who handles claims, especially when a broker is involved.
A broker is worth considering when the aim is to see several options through one conversation. Buying direct suits a business that has already settled on a carrier. On either route, the lowest premium that leaves a required cover unfilled, or an exclusion that matters to the trade, is not the better deal.
Sources
- U.S. Small Business Administration, "Get business insurance"
- Insurance Information Institute, "Commercial general liability insurance"
- Insurance Information Institute, "What does a business owners policy (BOP) cover"
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners, "Small business insurance shopping tool"
- Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, "Learn how business insurance works"
- Texas Department of Insurance, "General liability insurance"
This is general information rather than legal, tax or accounting advice, and requirements vary and change.