The best small business insurance provider is the one that will write the specific cover a business's trade requires at a quote that can be compared, and among the six covered here, Hiscox, NEXT Insurance, The Hartford and Insureon each publish cost figures worth anchoring against. Hiscox says general liability starts at $30 a month, The Hartford reports about $810 a year across its own customers, and NEXT Insurance, now branded ERGO NEXT, reports 45% of its customers paying $45 a month or less. Chubb and Thimble publish no premium, and Insureon is a broker, not a carrier. None of these figures is a market rate, and forming an LLC does not remove the need for cover.
What does "best" mean when choosing a small business insurance provider?
No single provider is best for every business, and this page does not rank them. Premiums depend on trade, payroll, revenue and location, so a provider that suits a personal trainer may be a poor fit for a restaurant. The six providers below are listed alphabetically, and the order is not a ranking.
What separates one option from another comes down to three questions. What kind of seller is it, an insurer or a broker? What does its published number actually describe, and who published it? And what does the policy leave out? Most comparison pages answer the first two loosely and skip the third, which is where a business owner's real exposure sits.
If the work is by the job or for a short period, Thimble's short-term and by-the-job approach may suit better than an annual policy. For a business that wants a published starting point, Hiscox, ERGO NEXT and The Hartford each give one. Where the number is missing, the honest answer is that a quote is the only way to find out.
Is a broker different from a carrier?
Yes, and the difference changes what the reader is buying. A carrier is the insurer that writes the policy and takes on the risk. A broker arranges cover with insurers, so the contract and the claims relationship may sit with an insurer the broker places the business with.
Insureon is a broker. That is not a weakness, but it is a reason to ask, for any policy bought through it, which insurer issues the policy and who handles a claim. The same question is worth asking of any provider, because a brand name on a website does not always tell a buyer who stands behind the cover.
The providers, in alphabetical order
Prices below were read at each provider's own pages and are as of October 13, 2026. Every figure belongs to the company that published it and describes that company's own customers or products. None of them is the market rate, and the cost of a specific policy will be higher or lower depending on the business.
Chubb. Chubb publishes no small-business premium, and it quotes per business. There is no figure to compare. The only way to place Chubb against the others is to request a quote for the same coverage.
Hiscox. Hiscox states that general liability starts at $30 a month. Its page lists what moves the price: business size, industry, location and coverage amount. Treat $30 as a floor, never as a typical price. It suits a buyer who wants a stated starting point to measure other quotes against.
Insureon. Insureon is a broker, not a carrier. It reports an average general liability premium of $45 a month, with 22% of its customers under $30 and 41% between $30 and $60, and annual policies running from $265 to $3,030. Those figures are the median of policies Insureon sold to roughly 100,000 of its own small business customers. They describe Insureon's book of business and should not be read as what the market charges.
NEXT Insurance. The company now brands itself ERGO NEXT. It says general liability starts at $19 a month for some businesses, and it reports that 45% of its customers pay $45 a month or less. It also publishes trade examples, from about $20 a month for a personal trainer to about $245 a month for a restaurant. The page itself says an exact price needs a quote, which makes the examples a guide to the range and not a price.
The Hartford. The Hartford publishes an average of about $810 a year, or about $67 a month, for general liability. That is the carrier's own average across its customers. Its page says costs vary by state and that a specific premium could be higher or lower. It is the most useful of the figures for seeing how a single carrier's average compares with another company's starting price, but only as a comparison of two different things.
Thimble. Thimble publishes no premium on its site and quotes per business. Its distinguishing feature is short-term and by-the-job cover, so it is best compared on that rather than on price. A business that works in short engagements or occasional events should weigh that against an annual policy from any of the others.
For a side-by-side view of what each company publishes and who the figure describes:
| Provider | What it publishes | What the figure describes |
|---|---|---|
| Chubb | No premium published | Quotes per business |
| Hiscox | General liability from $30 a month | A starting floor |
| Insureon | Average $45 a month; annual policies $265 to $3,030 | Median of policies sold to its own customers |
| NEXT Insurance | From $19 a month for some businesses; 45% of customers at $45 a month or less | Its own customers |
| The Hartford | About $810 a year, roughly $67 a month | Its own customers' average |
| Thimble | No premium published | Quotes per business |
What does general liability leave out?
The Insurance Information Institute describes general liability as cover for liability arising from non-professional negligent acts. That wording matters, because it separates general liability from the professional advice or services a business may sell. Within that scope, bodily injury and property damage cover protects against claims by others who are hurt or whose property is damaged.
Personal and advertising injury is covered too, including libel, slander, false arrest, infringing on another's copyright and malicious prosecution. Medical payments cover can be triggered without legal action, which means a small injury can be paid without a lawsuit.
The exclusions are where a policy is easiest to misjudge. Workers' compensation and employment practices liability are excluded but can be bought as separate policies. Pollution liability is excluded and can be added as an endorsement. Liquor liability, professional liability and other risks may also be excluded, and without the extra liquor cover a standard policy does not protect a business against liquor-related claims.
What does a business owners policy bundle?
A business owners policy, usually called a BOP, packages several covers together. The Insurance Information Institute lists three: property insurance for buildings and contents the company owns, business interruption insurance for loss of income when a fire or other catastrophe disrupts operations, and liability protection for the company's legal responsibility for harm it may cause others. It is aimed at small and mid-sized businesses that generally face the same kind and degree of risk.
The limits matter as much as the contents. In the Institute's words, "BOPs do NOT cover professional liability, auto insurance, worker's compensation or health and disability insurance." A business with employees therefore still needs workers' compensation separately, and one that gives professional advice needs professional liability separately.
A bundle is convenient, but it is not a complete program. A buyer who sees "business owners policy" and assumes everything is handled has misread what the policy is for.
Does forming an LLC remove the need for insurance?
No, and the U.S. Small Business Administration says so directly. Limited liability protects personal assets in most instances, but the agency states that the protection has limits. A page that implies forming an entity removes the need for cover contradicts that guidance.
The two things do different jobs. If someone runs a single-member LLC, the entity separates the business from the owner in most instances, while a policy pays for covered claims the business faces. One does not stand in for the other.
ZenBusiness is the entity half of that pairing. It sells no insurance of any kind, and it is not an option in the comparison above. For the question of which policy or which carrier, the answer is an insurer or a broker, and a reader forming an LLC should treat the entity and the cover as two separate decisions.
What does the law require?
The SBA states that the federal government requires every business with employees to carry workers' compensation, unemployment and disability insurance. It adds that some states require additional insurance and that laws requiring insurance vary by state. For anything beyond those three, the rule depends on where the business operates.
The place to confirm a state's rule is that state's own insurance department. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners publishes a small business insurance shopping tool, and the Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner publishes a guide to how business insurance works. The Texas Department of Insurance publishes a page on general liability insurance. A business in another state should look for its own department's equivalent, because this page does not state a requirement for any state beyond what the SBA covers.
What moves the price of small business insurance?
The inputs are consistent across the providers even where the numbers are not. Trade, payroll, revenue and location drive the premium, and coverage amount moves it too. Hiscox names business size, industry, location and coverage amount, and The Hartford says state affects its cost.
That is why a published average or starting price cannot be turned into a forecast. ERGO NEXT's own examples span about $20 a month to about $245 a month, a spread of more than tenfold, and those are two trades from one company. A personal trainer and a restaurant do not carry the same risk, so they do not pay the same.
How should a small business compare quotes?
Ask each provider to quote the same coverage, so the comparison is between like policies. Ask what the policy excludes, using the exclusions above as a checklist: workers' compensation, employment practices, pollution, liquor and professional liability. Ask who issues the policy and who handles claims, especially when buying through a broker.
Then check the state's insurance department for any requirement specific to the business. A low quote that leaves a legally required cover unfilled, or an exclusion that matters to the trade, is not a saving.
Sources
- Insurance Information Institute, "Commercial general liability insurance"
- U.S. Small Business Administration, "Get business insurance"
- Insurance Information Institute, "What does a business owners policy (BOP) cover"
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners, "Small business insurance shopping tool"
- Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, "Learn how business insurance works"
- Texas Department of Insurance, "General liability insurance"
This is general information rather than legal, tax or accounting advice, and requirements vary and change.