For a small service business, neither Hiscox nor The Hartford is the best general liability provider in every case, and the only way to find out which is cheaper is to request quotes for the same business from both. Hiscox states that general liability starts at $30 a month, which is a floor and not a typical price. The Hartford publishes an average of about $810 a year, or about $67 a month, across its own customers, and its page says a specific premium could be higher or lower. Those two figures measure different things, so they cannot be set side by side as a price comparison.
Which is better for a small service business, Hiscox or The Hartford?
The honest answer is that it depends on quotes neither company has published. Premiums depend on trade, payroll, revenue and location, so a cleaner, a consultant and a contractor can receive very different prices from the same carrier. This page does not rate either company, and it does not claim to have used either one.
What can be said is what each publishes. Hiscox gives a stated starting point and names the factors that move it. The Hartford gives an average across its customers and says a specific premium could be higher or lower. For a buyer, Hiscox's figure shows the lowest the price can start, and The Hartford's shows roughly where its own customers land.
The two paths to a decision are the same. Describe the business identically to both, request the same coverage amount, and compare what comes back, including what each policy excludes.
The two carriers, in alphabetical order
The order is alphabetical, not a ranking. Prices are as of October 13, 2026, were read at each provider's own pages, and move over time.
Hiscox. Hiscox states that general liability starts at $30 a month. Its page says business size, industry, location and coverage amount move the figure. Treat $30 as a floor, never as a typical price. For a service business, that makes it a useful lower bound when judging whether another quote is unusually high.
The Hartford. The Hartford publishes an average of about $810 a year, or about $67 a month, for general liability. That is the carrier's own average across its customers, not a market rate. Its page says costs vary by state and that a specific premium could be higher or lower, so the average should not be read as a quote.
| Hiscox | The Hartford | |
|---|---|---|
| What it publishes | General liability from $30 a month | About $810 a year, roughly $67 a month |
| What the figure describes | A starting floor | Its own customers' average |
| What the company says moves it | Business size, industry, location, coverage amount | Varies by state; a specific premium could be higher or lower |
Can the two published figures be compared directly?
No, and treating them as comparable is the most common error in pages like this one. A starting price is the bottom of a range. An average sits somewhere inside a range, pulled by whatever mix of businesses the carrier insures.
Set $30 beside $67 and it looks as if Hiscox is less than half the price. That conclusion is not supported. A business that falls in Hiscox's low end may pay far more than $30, and a business that sits near The Hartford's average may pay less than $67 or more. Only matching quotes settle it.
What does general liability actually cover?
The Insurance Information Institute says bodily injury and property damage cover protects against liability for harm to others arising out of non-professional negligent acts. For a service business, that fits ordinary risks such as a visitor injured on site or a client's property damaged during a job. Personal and advertising injury is covered too, including libel, slander, false arrest, infringing on another's copyright and malicious prosecution. Medical payments cover can be triggered without legal action.
The words "non-professional" are the part service businesses most often miss. The advice, design, analysis or specialist work a business sells is the part general liability does not reach, which is why professional liability is a separate question for any provider.
What does a general liability policy leave out?
Exclusions are where two similar premiums actually differ. Workers' compensation and employment practices liability are excluded but can be bought as separate policies. Pollution liability is excluded and can be added as an endorsement. Liquor liability, professional liability and other risks may also be excluded, and without the extra liquor cover a standard policy does not protect a business against liquor-related claims.
This page does not state which of these either carrier offers, or at what price. The practical step is to ask both carriers the same questions: is each of these excluded, and can it be added or bought separately?
Is a business owners policy an alternative?
A business owners policy, or BOP, bundles property insurance for buildings and contents the company owns, business interruption insurance for lost income after a fire or other catastrophe, and liability protection for harm the company may cause others. The Institute says it is aimed at small and mid-sized businesses that generally face the same kind and degree of risk.
A service business that holds equipment or works from its own premises may find the bundle useful. The limits are plain: "BOPs do NOT cover professional liability, auto insurance, worker's compensation or health and disability insurance." So a BOP does not close the professional liability gap either.
What does the law require?
The SBA states that the federal government requires every business with employees to carry workers' compensation, unemployment and disability insurance. It adds that some states require additional insurance and that laws requiring insurance vary by state. A general liability policy from either carrier does not satisfy those requirements.
The place to confirm a state's rule is that state's own insurance department. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners publishes a small business insurance shopping tool, the Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner has a guide to how business insurance works, and the Texas Department of Insurance has a page on general liability insurance. This page does not state a requirement for any particular state.
Does an LLC remove the need for general liability?
No. The SBA says limited liability protects personal assets in most instances, but that the protection has limits. The entity and the policy do different jobs, and one does not stand in for the other.
If someone runs a single-member LLC, the entity separates the business from the owner in most instances, while a policy pays for covered claims the business faces. ZenBusiness is the entity half of that pairing. It sells no insurance of any kind and is not part of the Hiscox and The Hartford comparison, so the choice of carrier is a separate decision.
How should a service business choose between them?
Request a quote from each for the same business: the same description of the work, the same revenue and payroll, the same location and the same coverage amount. Ask each what the policy excludes and whether professional liability can be added or bought separately. Ask what the deductible is, because this page does not state typical figures.
Then check the state insurance department for anything legally required. A lower premium that leaves a required cover unfilled, or an exclusion that matters to the trade, is not a saving.
Sources
- Insurance Information Institute, "Commercial general liability insurance"
- Insurance Information Institute, "What does a business owners policy (BOP) cover"
- U.S. Small Business Administration, "Get business insurance"
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners, "Small business insurance shopping tool"
- Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, "Learn how business insurance works"
- Texas Department of Insurance, "General liability insurance"
This is general information rather than legal, tax or accounting advice, and requirements vary and change.